Wall Street Journal
JULY 20, 2011
Attack of the Urban Mosquitoes
Aggressive and Hard to Kill: Two Asian Cityslickers Swarm the East Coast
The latest scourge crossing the country has a taste for the big city.
The Asian tiger mosquito, named for its distinctive black-and-white striped body, is a relatively new species to the U.S. that is more vicious, harder to kill and, unlike most native mosquitoes, bites during the daytime. It also prefers large cities over rural or marshy areas—thus earning the nickname among entomologists as “the urban mosquito.”
“Part of the reason it is called ‘tiger’ is also because it is very aggressive,” says Dina Fonseca, an associate professor of entomology at Rutgers University. “You can try and swat it all you want, but once it’s on you, it doesn’t let go. Even if it goes away, it will be back for a bite.”
Swat Team: What Works
- Look for brands containing DEET, such as Off! Deep Woods, and products containing Picaridin, such as Cutter Skinsations.
- Oil of lemon eucalyptus is a repellent that uses natural materials.
- For the Asian tiger, use a mosquito trap that emits carbon dioxide (Dragonfly II shown at left.) Add what’s called a lure that contains lactic acid to attract daytime mosquitoes. Lures with octenol attract other mosquito species.
- Sources: Dr. Bruce Robinson; Ron Crittenden, owner of mosquitocentral.com; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
- Here are some ways to ease the pain of mosquito bites, according to Bruce Robinson, a clinical instructor of dermatology at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York.
- In general, treating with heat or cold can offer relief by confusing the brain, he says. It’s like when you hit your knee and then rub it to make it hurt less. “Even though it doesn’t actually hurt less, the sensation of touch reaches your brain earlier than the pain, and you feel that it helps with the hurt,” he says.
- Ice. An ice pack decreases inflammation and reduces itching.
- Anti-itch lotions. Creams containing 1% hydrocortisone reduce inflammation. Products that contain camphor and menthol, such as Sarna, also help. To boost the effect, store the lotions in the refrigerator. (Note: Calamine lotion dries out the affected area and therefore is not recommended.)
- Benadryl. It stops the release of histamine, which triggers inflammation.
- Therapik. This device, approved by the Food and Drug Administration, delivers heat to the affected area to reduce itching and inflammation.
- Toothpaste. It helps, but only if it contains menthol.
POPULAR BUT UNPROVEN
- Paste of baking soda and water
- Apple-cider vinegar
- Lemon juice
- Cigarette smoke
- Fabric-softener dryer sheets
Sources: Dr. Bruce Robinson; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Dr. Fonseca is leading a U.S. Department of Agriculture effort to develop a cost-effective method to control the Asian tiger mosquito(Aedes albopictus) population. The university is currently focusing on using larvacides, which render larvae incapable of growing into adults.
Since urban areas tend to be warmer—often by 5 to 10 degrees—than rural areas, cities are seeing tiger mosquitoes earlier and sticking around longer, often into October.
“The Asian tiger mosquito arrived this year in June—three months earlier than last year,” says Wayne Andrews, superintendent of the Bristol County Mosquito Control Project in Taunton, Mass.
The species has been traced to 1985, when a ship arrived in Texas loaded with used truck tires, perhaps from Japan, which is a major used-tire exporter, according to research by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The eggs hatched when they were exposed to water. Since then, the species has made its way from Texas to Florida and up the East Coast, says Gary G. Clark, a research leader with the Agriculture Department. “Now, more than half of the states have this aggressive species,” he says.
Another species imported from Asia is the rock pool mosquito (Aedes japonicus), which also came to the U.S. through the tire trade, experts say. This species is blackish-brown, with white scales on the lower part of its thorax and legs. It was first detected on Long Island, N.Y., and in areas of New Jersey in 1997, according to Dr. Fonseca. “Even though it is not as vicious a biter as the Asian tiger mosquito, it is a big pest,” she says.
These urban mosquitoes are what entomologists call “container mosquitoes.” Instead of marshes and natural bodies of water, both Asian tiger and rock pool mosquitoes can breed in small, artificial containers, such as tires, toys, cans and concrete structures. “A rule of thumb for container mosquitoes is: Water plus seven days equals mosquitoes,” Dr. Fonseca says.
Weather patterns can help Asian tigers readily spread beyond the Northeast. “As a result of climate change, the summer lasts longer and arrives earlier,” says Andrew Comrie, a climatologist at the University of Arizona. Eggs of Asian tiger and rock pool mosquitoes are also able to “overwinter,” meaning they can survive a cold, dry climate—all they need is exposure to water in warmer temperatures.
The Asian tiger was responsible for transmitting more than 200 cases of dengue fever, a sometimes-fatal viral infection, in Hawaii in 2001-02. A similar (but less lethal) virus called chikungunya was transmitted in France and Italy, but no cases have been cited in the U.S. from the Asian tiger. Likewise, the rock pool mosquito is capable of transmitting the West Nile virus, but no cases have been traced to the species in the U.S., Dr. Fonseca says.
That does little to take the sting out of their bites. Irritation and itching are the body’s allergic reaction to the protein secreted from the female mosquito when it bites.
Cities that spray for mosquitoes may find these latest breeds tough to tackle. “The usual methods of spraying cannot control the population of these species because their preferred breeding areas are difficult to reach,” says Mr. Andrews, the Massachusetts mosquito-control agent.
Moreover, the optimum conditions for spraying are early evening, after these mosquitoes retire. Also, Dr. Fonseca, the Rutgers entomologist, explains that spraying kills only the adult mosquitoes and not the eggs or larvae.
To reduce the chances of getting bitten, remove containers that have standing water in them. The best personal protection comes from products that contain DEET. The chemical has been controversial, but “as long as you don’t bathe in DEET or inhale too much of it, you should be fine,” says Bruce Robinson, a clinical instructor of dermatology at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York. Since the tiger is a low-flying mosquito, keep ankles and legs covered. Also, the Asian tiger is a very visual mosquito, Dr. Fonseca says. “If you wear dark-colored clothes, you will be inviting it to bite you.